While the color of one’s teeth may appear to be the only concern when it comes to tooth whitening kits, the color of the solution itself can actually play a significant role, as it plays a major part in that consumer’s perception of quality and efficacy; while the results of a tooth whitening solution matter, the color of the solution matters just as much and manufacturers generally aim for a clear end product that suggests a vivid, clean result. Although these associations are in part psychological, color can also be a very real sign of efficacy, making strict color quality control critical.
Unfortunately, when working with multiple chemicals, color accuracy and consistency can be difficult to maintain. Slight reactions between the components of your solution could cause the color to turn an unappealing shade, become cloudy, or cause the active ingredient to break down, reducing the impact of the blend. Because the color of oral care products such as whitening solutions has both significant aesthetic and functional implications, it is important that operators are able to locate and resolve color problems rapidly. This can be achieved by integrating spectrophotometric color measurement as a central component of your color quality control protocols.
Why Color Matters in Tooth Whitening Solutions
Typically, the active ingredient in whitening solution is either hydrogen peroxide or carbamide peroxide, which are naturally clear or white in color. However, both hydrogen peroxide and carbamide peroxide are susceptible to color changes in the presence of other substances, potentially decreasing aesthetic appeal or product efficacy.1 This is a significant concern, as at-home tooth bleaching solutions are not primarily comprised of their active chemicals; water makes up the largest portion of any solution and mineral deposits in that water can cause a color change when exposed to peroxides and other bleaching agents. Hydrogen peroxide, in particular, is unstable and as such, there is a wide range of minerals which will react poorly with it. These minerals, such as iron, copper, bronze, chromium, zinc, lead, manganese, chloride and silver, are commonly found in water. Even in trace amounts, such minerals have the potential to react poorly with the hydrogen, causing the solution to change color and become less effective.2 Using demineralized water doesn’t entirely guarantee there will be no minerals impacting the hydrogen peroxide in your solution. For example, a small amount of hydrogen peroxide mixed with iron can cause the color of the solution to shift, creating a subtle, unappealing yellow or brownish tint.
In the past, the hydrogen peroxide was kept in a separate tube, which was only combined with the other ingredients once the consumer was ready to use the product. This reduced the risk of unappealing color changes and ensured the product remained stable. Advances in bleaching chemistry, such as the development of solid bleaching agents, have changed this practice and active ingredients no longer have to be kept separate, as chemical reactions are delayed. However, with these advances come the increased risk of an unappealing color result or reduced effectiveness of product due to chemical combinations.3 When the color of a solution changes, this could be an indicator that an undesired chemical reaction has occurred. In addition to color change, hard minerals like calcium and salt have the potential to turn a clear solution cloudy. This haze is another indicator that an unwanted chemical reaction has occurred in your solution and may cause customers to question the quality of the product.
Choosing the Right Spectrophotometer
Identifying color and haze issues in whitening solutions isn’t simple, as the naked eye may not pick up on the subtle color and haze difference. Spectrophotometers, however, allow for objective color and haze measurement by distilling these parameters to numerical data, allowing for exacting accuracy and precision. Due to the sensitivity of spectrophotometric instrumentation, even the most subtle color and haze differences can be detected, including those which are typically unseen by the human eye. As such, spectrophotometric technology gives you extraordinary insight into product behavior and the ability to identify unwanted variations early, helping you pinpoint any issues with trace elements in your solution, incorrect formulation, or incorrect processing.
However, choosing the right spectrophotometer is essential to obtaining the most reliable results from your spectrophotometric testing. Today, there are more spectrophotometric options available than ever before, presenting new possibilities for color and haze analysis. One instrument, however, has the unique ability to measure transmission color and haze simultaneously: the HunterLab Vista.
The Vista is a revolutionary instrument that combines color and haze measurement into one simple step, reducing sample preparation time and improving efficiency of measurement. With one-touch standardization, a modern touchscreen display, and embedded Essentials software providing customizable workspaces, and multiple data views, the Vista allows for both ease of use and sophistication of data analysis. Its spill-resistant sample compartment and small footprint mean it is ideal for measuring the color of liquid samples in virtually any laboratory environment. Data is easily managed through Ethernet communications, direct from the instrument print and email capability, and real-time data streaming to users SPC, LIMS and other data collection systems.
Realizing the Benefits of Simultaneous Color and Haze Measurement
Integrating the right spectrophotometer in your quality control process can have significant benefits, allowing you to ensure only the highest quality, most appealing products enter the marketplace. This helps you create trusting, long-lasting relationships with your customers. At the same time, combining color and haze measurement into one step allows for more efficient product analysis, reducing labor time and risk of operator error. Meanwhile, early detection of color and haze changes can help you make formulation and process changes to enhance product aesthetics and performance as well as production efficiency. In doing so, you can not only produce the best possible product, but realize meaningful cost savings as product waste and rework are minimized.
Are you ready to take your color quality control methods to the next level? For manufacturers of tooth whitening solutions and other transparent or translucent oral care products, the Vista presents new possibilities for perfecting both products and production. In addition the Vista, HunterLab offers a full range of benchtop, portable, and on-line instruments for accurately and precisely analyzing a wide range of products in the oral care industry. Contact us to learn more about our renowned instruments and let us help you select the right tools for your needs.
- “Statement on the Safety and Effectiveness of Tooth Whitening Products.” https://www.ada.org/en/about-the-ada/ada-positions-policies-and-statements/tooth-whitening-safety-and-effectiveness ↩
- “NIOSH Pocket Guide to Chemical Hazards – Hydrogen Peroxide.” https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/npg/npgd0335.html ↩
- “Teeth Whitening Solution.” http://www.madehow.com/Volume-6/Teeth-Whitener.html ↩
Mr. Philips has spent the last 30 years in product development and management, technical sales, marketing, and business development in several industries. Today, he is the global market development manager for HunterLab, focused on understanding customer needs, providing appropriate solutions and education, and helping to solve customer color challenges across these industries and cultures.